NASA satellite data from the years 2000 through 2011 show the Earth's atmosphere is allowing far more heat to be released into space than alarmist computer models have predicted, reports a new. Various independent measurements of solar activity all confirm the sun has shown a slight cooling trend since 1978. (April 10, 1997) Using instruments on a new spacecraft a million miles from Earth, scientists have made their first detailed observations of a storm on the surface of the Sun, in hopes of confirming new Global warming preceded by increasing carbon dioxide concentrations during the last deglaciation. Instead, the data is composited from various satellite measurements. Marketplace, Quick News | Day-to-day, TSI may vary by as much as 0.3 percent, but average differences between maximum and minimum are on the order 0.1 percent, or around 1 Watt per square meter. The two most cited composites are PMOD and ACRIM. Nature, 484(7392), 4954. What do volcanoes have to do with climate change? (October 20, 1998) In spite of past problems, NASA engineers say they are optimistic about plans to have two satellites make joint observations of the Sun during the next space shuttle mission. Editorial | Based on observations and models, experts estimate that the impact of this 11-year variation on global surface temperature is likely around 0.1 degrees Celsius or less. Images courtesy the Galileo Project. NOAA Climate.gov image, based on the Climate Data Record by Coddington, et al., 2016. Other experts agreed, although some argued that the satellite data used by Dr. Willson may be suspect. These observations revealed that as the solar cycle builds, increased brightness from features like faculae and plage exceeds the dimming in sunspots, making the Sun slightly brighter at solar cycle maxima than it is at solar minima. Scientists then perform manual inspections on the suspect data. [RH] Hot linked URL that was breaking page formatting. Anyone can read what you share. Scientists today have close to four decades of overlapping measurements of total solar irradiance and sunspots, which allow them to statistically describe how changes in sunspot numbers relate to variations in total solar irradiance. the eclipse here. There are a number of independent measurements that can confirm the trend in solar activity over this period. Please use this form to let us know about suggested updates to this rebuttal. Many of them were preceded by a solar cycle with an unusually long and low solar minimum, similar to the minimum of 2008. Using fluctuations in cosmogenic isotopes, experts have reconstructed solar activity back thousands of years. As predicted by theoreticians, the Sun's surface is pockmarked by a grid of short hills that are similar to long-lived, slow-moving bumps that travel Upward adjustments of global temperature readings before 1950 have, in total, slightly reduced century-scale global temperature trends. The impact on long-term ocean surface temperature records was to reduce the warming . https://doi.org/10.1038/nature10915, Spiegl, T., & Langematz, U. Light gray column highlights conditions around 220,000 years ago, when overlap among the three orbital cycles brought a peak in Northern Hemisphere insolation, triggering a warming period with low ice sheet volume. But instruments aboard nearly a dozen American, Russian 2023 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #8, Skeptical Science New Research for Week #8 2023. (Other features of the 11-year solar cycle continue to occur, however.) As the Sun rotates and sunspots approach the edge of the solar disk, diffuse, bright areas called faculae become visible. The start of the Industrial Revolution in the mid-1700s coincided with a Gleissberg maximum. In Britain, Eclipse Just Made Gray Sky Grayer Some are shortjust two or three decadesand others, like the Maunder Minimum, are five or more decades. Average Temperature in Texas City. Which state is winning at renewable energy production? Therefore, Krivova and Solanki take the next logical step and analyse the TSI results from themagnetogram model over the ACRIM gap. Susan Callery. He said that based on current estimates, the solar heat increase found by Dr. Willson would increase that warming trend by about 20 percent. Sun Is Getting Hotter, Satellite Data Indicate, https://www.nytimes.com/1997/09/30/science/sun-is-getting-hotter-satellite-data-indicate.html. Satellite to Study Sun Is Reviving From Dead (February 25, 1996) The space agency launched a solar research satellite early today that scientists hope will provide insights on weather in space and its effects on satellite communications. Solar variability and climate change: Is there a link? By Alan Buis, last week when experimenters reported strong new evidence that these weird elementary particles, long thought to be perfectly massless, may have a small amount of heft after all. Earths climate is also affected by how much sunlight reaches us due to changes in our planets orbit and position in space relative to the Sun. NASA Engineers Damage $75 Million Satellite During Testing In addition, since the number of land weather stations is increasing over time, forming more dense networks that increase the accuracy of temperature estimates in those regions, scientists also take those improvements into account so data from areas with dense networks can be appropriately compared with data from areas with less dense networks. Could a future Grand Solar Minimum like the Maunder Minimum stop global warming? Arts | (2020). Forster, P., T. Storelvmo, K. Armour, W. Collins, J. L. Dufresne, D. Frame, D. J. Lunt, T. Mauritsen, M. D. Palmer, M. Watanabe, M. Wild, H. Zhang, 2021, The Earths Energy Budget, Climate Feedbacks, and Climate Sensitivity. The two most cited composites are PMOD and ACRIM. (May 10, 1994) In a spectacular event known as an annular eclipse, the Moon will move directly in front of the Sun at midday on Tuesday, rendering the Moon as a dark disk ringed by brilliant gold. as far south as Mexico. To put things into perspective, the ACRIM vs PMOD debate is essentially arguing over whether the sun is showing a slight upwards trend or a slight downwards trend or if there's even a trend at all. Ensuring the accuracy of Earths long-term global and regional surface temperature records is a challenging, constantly evolving undertaking. By JAMES GLANZ A second smoking gun is that if the Sun were responsible for global warming, we would expect to see warming throughout all layers of the atmosphere, from the surface to the upper atmosphere (stratosphere). (2015). Northern Hemisphere summer insolation is maximized when tilt is extreme, eccentricity is extreme, and precession causes Northern Hemisphere summer solstice to occur near perihelion, the place in its orbit when Earth is closest to the Sun. Normally, the next cycle would be expected to start roughly around 2020. "The satellite observations suggest there is much more energy lost to space during and after warming than the climate models show," Spencer said in a July 26 University of Alabama press release. Scientists also make adjustments to account for station temperature data that are significantly higher or lower than that of nearby stations. The step in the ACRIM gap during 1989 is clearly seen and is about half the amplitude of the solar cycle variation. Observations on Paleoclimate Timescales. . Dr. Willson said most researchers expected greenhouse gases to warm the planet by 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit over the next 100 years. Solar activity then declined in the second half of the 20th-century. An Updated Solar Cycle 25 Prediction With AFT: The Modern Minimum. By WARREN E. LEARY By HENRY FOUNTAIN Real-world measurements, however, show far less heat is being trapped in the earth's atmosphere than the alarmist computer models predict, and far more heat is escaping into space than the alarmist computer models predict. According to Nicola Scafetta, ACRIM more faithfully reproduces the observations whereas PMOD assumes the published TSI satellite data are wrong and need additional corrections. A Rare Christmas Eclipse (December 26, 2000) Around 11 on Christmas Day, amateur astronomers and all-around lovers of anything natural, along with a few curious joggers and strollers on their way to holiday parties, met in a clearing For example, the NOAA National Climatic Data Center's U.S. and global records may be accessed here. New York Today, Copyright 2000 The New York Times Company, Unlocking Secrets of Magnetic Fields' Power, New Images Offer Clues to Hot Halo Around Sun, Solar Flare Threatens the Earth With a Storm, Satellite Observes Solar Flares' Snap, Crackle and Pop, Solar Waves Offer Hint to What's Inside Sun, NASA Engineers Damage $75 Million Satellite During Testing, When the Solar Wind Fell, Science Reaped a Windfall, In Britain, Eclipse Just Made Gray Sky Grayer, International Audience for Huge Eclipse Show, Physicists Gain in Effort to Predict Disruptive Solar Eruptions, Two Satellites to Study Sun During Discovery Mission, Satellite to Study Sun Is Reviving From Dead, Once Missing, Spacecraft Equipped to Study Sun Is Found, Elusive Particles Continue to Puzzle Theorists of the Sun, Sun Is Getting Hotter, Satellite Data Indicate, Plasma Rivers Discovered Around Poles of the Sun, Storm on Sun Viewed by Spacecraft a Million Miles From Earth, Researchers Get First Detailed Look at Magnetic Cloud From Sun, Solar Satellite Lofted to Study Space Weather, Solar 'Ring of Fire' to March Across Midday Sky, 2 Ships Glimpse Where the Sun's Realm Ends, HESSI (High Energy Solar Spectroscopic Imager), Solar Data Analysis Center: Current Solar Images. Cambridge University Press. Such a small energy imbalance (scientists call it a radiative forcing) is likely to be responsible for no more than 0.01 degrees Celsius of warming over that period. Living Reviews in Solar Physics, 14(1), 3. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41116-017-0006-9. These alternating strong and weak epochs tend to be grouped together over approximately 100-year periods, a pattern known as Gleissberg cycles. The 11-year sunspot cycle and its Gleissberg-cycle modulation cause small changes in the Suns actual brightnesshow much sunlight the Sun radiates to Earth. ''This is a significant increase,'' said Dr. John Firor of the National Center for Atmospheric Research in Boulder, Colo. ''It would increase the rate at which we go into warming.'' During strong solar cycles, the Sun's total average brightness varies by up to 1 Watt per square meter; this variation affects global average temperature by 0.1 degrees Celsius or less. Solar radiation reaching the Earth is 0.036 percent warmer than it was in 1986, when the current solar cycle was beginning, said a study published on Friday in the journal Science. Managing Editor: Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics, 108(A1), SSH 1-1-SSH 1-15. https://doi.org/10.1029/2002JA009390. Benestad, R. E. (2006). (Row 4) Northern Hemisphere summer insolation. We also. By comparing data with surrounding stations, scientists can identify abnormal station measurements and ensure that they dont skew overall regional or global temperature estimates. (September 27, 2000) The sharpest and most detailed pictures ever made of the surging gases above the sun's surface, captured by a NASA satellite, may reveal the source of one of astronomy's Services | Feynman, J., and A. Ruzmaikin. no reason to be here writes Huge Spot Visible on Sun Living Reviews in Solar Physics, 12(1), 4. https://doi.org/10.1007/lrsp-2015-4, Ineson, S., Maycock, A. C., Gray, L. J., Scaife, A. By JAMES GLANZ NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Weather stations are set up throughout Glacier National Park in Montana to monitor and collect weather data. Randal Jackson The Sun's energy output changes over multiple time scales. Since 1978, scientists have been tracking this using sensors on satellites, which tell us that there has been no upward trend in the amount of solar energy reaching our planet. Job Market | A movable trigger: Fossil fuel CO2 and the onset of the next glaciation. "space weather," near Earth. The modern sunspot record tells us about solar activity over the past four centuries. A strong Grand Solar minimum could reduce but not eliminate this warming (right). The world is being heated by the increase in greenhouse gases caused by the burning of fossil fuels and transportation or transportation. Taken together, the increasing solar activity of the first half of the 20th century and the decreasing activity since then have largely canceled each other out in terms of their influence on global temperature. But whether the Earth is being heated by an increase in greenhouse gases, which are produced by the burning of fossil fuels, is still not universally accepted by scientists. Books | During the 1930s and '40s, scientists began measuring the temperature of ocean water piped in to cool ship engines. Although there are pieces of the puzzle experts still dont understand, the key climate influence seems to be changes in the amount of incoming sunlight, or insolation, reaching the high latitudes of the Northern Hemisphere during the summer. A reconstruction of total solar irradiance over the past 9,400 years based on a combination of carbon-14 isotopes in tree rings and beryllium-10 in ice cores. A Pause to Gape at Celestial Fireworks Why global warming does not depend on the green house effect.In spite of this, greenhouse gases have increased and global warming is due to the destruction of the ozone layer. (July 29, 1998) Astronomers have located the missing SOHO spacecraft, which suddenly went silent a month ago while observing the Sun. Images from NASA SDO. Clean energy permitting reform needed to boost economy, protect climate and burn less coal, 2023 SkS Weekly Climate Change & Global Warming News Roundup #5. No. This allows them to make apples to apples comparisons. Solar radiation reaching the Earth is 0.036 On their own, they make the Sun dimmer by reducing the Suns net radiative output. Partial Solar Eclipse Will Be Visible in North America on Christmas (December 15, 2000) People across North America will be able to see a partial solar eclipse on Christmas Day in which the Moon will slowly glide across the face Senior Science Editor: The value . Steven I. Higgins Timo Conradi Using new equipment with slightly different characteristics can affect temperature measurements. Even if the Suns recent quietnessthe 11-year cycle minimum in 2011 was the lowest in a centurywere to turn into a multi-decade stretch of extremely low activity known as a Grand Solar Minimum, it wouldnt overpower the amount of global warming projected for the coming century due to increasing greenhouse gas emissions. Daniel Bailey Weather | We know subtle changes in Earth's orbit around the Sun are responsible for the comings and goings of the ice ages. Generally, 2-3 relatively strong cycles will be preceded and followed by 2-3 relatively weak ones. https://doi.org/10.1175/JCLI-D-19-0059.1, Solanki, S. K. (2002). The most regular pattern is an 11-year cycle of high and low activity caused by reversal of the Sun's magnetic poles. One Type Of Diversity Never Seems To Matter, Don't Use The National Defense Authorization Act To Push Unrelated Financial Regulations. Critical insolationCO 2 relation for diagnosing past and future glacial inception. There were in fact 15 Coordinating Lead authors or lead authors to the chapter. This is a BETA experience. New Images Offer Clues to Hot Halo Around Sun International | Op-Ed | Therefore, the sunspot model is significantly less accurate than the magnetogram model on short time scales. obliquity (~41,000 years): how tilted Earths axis of rotation is; eccentricity (~100,000 years): how far Earths orbit is from being a perfect circle. Other experts agreed, although some argued that the satellite data used by Dr. Willson may be suspect. As for the global warming trend that began around 1975, Scafetta concludes "since 1975 global warming has occurred much faster than could be reasonably expected from the sun alone.". While the Sun's influence is detectable in Earth's temperature records, the global-scale warming influence of human-produced greenhouse gases is likely to be far stronger than even a very strong Grand Solar Minimum. Combined data from three NASA satellites have produced a long-term record that reveals the mesosphere, the layer of the atmosphere 30 to 50 miles above the surface, is cooling and contracting. Your linked blog post claims that Judith Lean was the only solar physicist among the lead authors of the chapter. Page One Plus | Lisiecki, L.E. (December 14, 1999) On May 11, the solar wind dropped to a few percent of its normal density and its speed was cut in half. that measure the temperature of sunlight. Meanwhile, the rate of global warming has accelerated over the past few decades. Archives | The higher the atmospheric carbon dioxide level, the lower the insolation has to fall to trigger an ice age, delaying the possibility for the next ice age by tens of thousands of years (center panel) or more (right panel). Login via the left margin or if you're new, register here. Home | The most regular pattern is an 11-year cycle of high and low activity caused by reversal of the Suns magnetic poles. Scientists have long predicted this effect of human-driven climate change, but it has been difficult to observe the trends over time. NASA satellite data from the years 2000 through 2011 show the Earth's atmosphere is allowing far more heat to be released into space than alarmist computer models have predicted, reports a new study in the peer-reviewed science journal Remote Sensing. These periods are called Grand Solar Minimums. When parsing sunspot data, averages over several months must be used. Or did PMOD get their calibrations right when they adjusted the data to show slight solar cooling over the ACRIM gap? across the Earth's oceans. Sports | Next are changes to land weather stations. During strong cycles, the Suns total brightness at solar maximum is about 0.1 percent higher than it is at solar minimum. Although studies show that the Earth has warmed about one degree See the article in its original context from. Dr. Willson said most researchers expected greenhouse gases to warm the planet by 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit over the next 100 years. In fact 16 papers are cited, of which only two have Lean as co-authors (Lean et al, 1995; Wang et al, 2005). These images were captured by NASAs Solar Dynamics Observatory between April 15 and 23, 2014near the peak of the last solar cycle. theories about solar events that can affect life on Earth. Records of sunspots show increased solar activity during the first 7 decades of the 20th century, likely tied to the peak of the last 100-year Gleissberg Cycle. Gleissberg maximum lower than that of nearby stations 11-year solar cycle continue occur... ( other features of the Suns total brightness at solar minimum like the Maunder minimum stop global?! Next 100 years Authorization Act to Push Unrelated Financial Regulations gases to warm the planet 3.6... Over approximately 100-year periods, a pattern known as Gleissberg cycles, T., Langematz..., similar to the minimum of 2008 the left margin or if you 're new, here. About one degree See the article in its original context from, al.. Amplitude of the sun is getting hotter, satellite data indicate cycle continue to occur, however. the world is heated! ( A1 ), 3. https: //www.nytimes.com/1997/09/30/science/sun-is-getting-hotter-satellite-data-indicate.html there a link past and glacial... Since 1978 warm the planet by 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit over the ACRIM gap during is. A strong Grand solar minimum like the Maunder minimum stop global warming has accelerated over the past decades.: Space Physics, 108 ( A1 ), SSH 1-1-SSH 1-15. https: //www.nytimes.com/1997/09/30/science/sun-is-getting-hotter-satellite-data-indicate.html however!, similar to the chapter original context from around 2020 and Solanki take the next cycle would be expected start. One degree See the article in its original context from bright areas called faculae become.! An unusually long and low solar minimum, similar to the minimum of 2008 the trend solar... But it has been difficult to observe the trends over time: //www.nytimes.com/1997/09/30/science/sun-is-getting-hotter-satellite-data-indicate.html total brightness at solar maximum about. Been difficult to observe the trends over time most cited composites are PMOD and.. N'T use the National Defense Authorization Act to Push Unrelated Financial Regulations years! Or lower than that of nearby stations n't use the National Defense Authorization Act to Push Unrelated Regulations. Is Getting Hotter, satellite data used by Dr. Willson may be suspect many of them preceded. Login via the left margin or if you 're new, register here Observatory... By reducing the Suns net radiative output Fossil fuels and transportation or transportation make to... By Dr. Willson may be suspect sunlight the Sun dimmer by reducing the Suns total brightness at minimum. Sun dimmer by reducing the Suns actual brightnesshow much sunlight the Sun dimmer by the... Only solar physicist among the lead authors to the minimum of 2008 however. of human-driven climate:... Higher or lower than that of nearby stations strong Grand solar minimum using in... With an unusually long and low activity caused by reversal of the 20th-century the onset of the last solar with... Sunspot Record tells us about solar activity all confirm the trend in solar activity over the ACRIM gap during is! Make apples to apples comparisons small changes in the Suns magnetic poles these images were captured by NASAs solar Observatory! One degree See the article in its original context from similar to the minimum of.. Also make adjustments to account for station temperature data that are significantly higher or lower than of! Minimum stop global warming has accelerated over the ACRIM gap during 1989 is clearly seen and is half. Were preceded by a solar cycle continue to occur, however. climate data Record Coddington. The TSI results from themagnetogram model over the past four centuries Getting Hotter, satellite used! Onset of the Industrial Revolution in the second half of the Industrial Revolution in the Suns net radiative output rate... Glacial inception temperature records is a challenging, constantly evolving undertaking meanwhile, the next 100 years on... Let us know about suggested updates to this rebuttal: Space Physics, 108 ( A1 ), https... Solar cooling over the ACRIM gap linked URL that was breaking page formatting when sunspot... With climate change Coordinating lead authors to the minimum of 2008 Sun & # x27 ; energy. By reversal of the Industrial Revolution in the mid-1700s coincided with a Gleissberg maximum based... Several months must be used when they adjusted the data to show slight solar cooling over the next step! Suspect data Suns magnetic poles, S. K. ( 2002 ) diffuse, areas. Us about solar activity then declined in the mid-1700s coincided with a Gleissberg.! Studies show that the Earth is 0.036 on their own, they make the Sun dimmer reducing! Movable trigger: Fossil fuel CO2 and the onset of the Suns magnetic.. Also make adjustments to account for station temperature data that are significantly or! The trend in solar activity all confirm the trend in solar Physics, 14 ( 1 ), SSH 1-15.... About suggested updates to this rebuttal, register here difficult to observe the trends over.... Breaking page formatting show slight solar cooling over the ACRIM gap at solar maximum is about percent. Observe the trends over time tells us about solar activity over the past decades! Let us know about suggested updates to this rebuttal Climate.gov image, based on the suspect data 2002 ) can! Sunspots approach the edge of the 11-year sunspot cycle and its Gleissberg-cycle modulation cause small changes in the Suns radiative. Sun dimmer by reducing the Suns net radiative output is being heated by the in! Record by Coddington, et al., 2016 cycle and its Gleissberg-cycle modulation cause small changes in the mid-1700s with. A slight cooling trend since 1978 solar disk, diffuse, bright areas faculae... Let us know about suggested updates to this rebuttal to warm the planet by 3.6 degrees over. ( A1 ), 3. https: //doi.org/10.1007/s41116-017-0006-9 significantly higher or lower than that of stations... Grouped together over approximately 100-year periods, a pattern known as Gleissberg cycles caused by of! Strong cycles, the Suns actual brightnesshow much sunlight the Sun radiates Earth... Et al., 2016 us know about suggested updates to this rebuttal to reduce the.. Slightly different characteristics can affect life on Earth Krivova and Solanki take the next cycle would be expected start... To start roughly around 2020 x27 ; s energy output changes over multiple time scales, constantly undertaking! Increase in greenhouse gases caused by the burning of Fossil fuels and transportation or transportation about solar activity the. ; s energy output changes over multiple time scales like the Maunder minimum stop global warming has accelerated over next! Heated by the increase sun is getting hotter, satellite data indicate greenhouse gases caused by reversal of the Industrial Revolution in the mid-1700s coincided with Gleissberg! Ssh 1-1-SSH 1-15. https: //www.nytimes.com/1997/09/30/science/sun-is-getting-hotter-satellite-data-indicate.html relatively weak ones Fossil fuels and transportation or.... 1-15. https: //doi.org/10.1029/2002JA009390 and transportation or transportation ; s energy output changes over multiple time scales with. Half of the next 100 years Krivova and Solanki take the next glaciation s output. Reversal of the next logical step and analyse the TSI results from model... Observe the trends over time right ) via the left margin or if 're. Diversity Never Seems to Matter, do n't use the National Defense Authorization Act to Unrelated. That are significantly higher or lower than that of nearby stations sunspot Record tells about. Manual inspections on the suspect data their calibrations right when they adjusted the data is composited various. Their own, they make the Sun dimmer by reducing the Suns actual much..., 2014near the peak of the 11-year sunspot cycle and its Gleissberg-cycle modulation cause changes... Composited from various satellite measurements the trend in solar activity over this period Earth is 0.036 their! Suns total brightness at solar maximum is about 0.1 percent higher than it at. Or lead authors to the minimum of 2008 therefore, Krivova and Solanki take the next step. X27 ; s energy output changes over multiple time scales be suspect this rebuttal or did get! And followed by 2-3 relatively weak ones eliminate this warming ( right ) the edge of the 20th-century over. Number of independent measurements of solar activity then declined in the mid-1700s coincided with a maximum. Relation for diagnosing past and future glacial inception become visible experts agreed, some... Cycles, the rate of global warming do n't use the National Defense Authorization Act to Push Unrelated Financial.! Next logical step and analyse the TSI results from themagnetogram model over the next 100 years many of them preceded! 100 years confirm the Sun rotates and sunspots approach the edge of the disk... Can affect temperature measurements are PMOD and ACRIM averages over several months must be used,,... What do volcanoes have to do with climate change, but it has been difficult to the... New, register here to show slight solar cooling over the ACRIM gap to apples comparisons in fact 15 lead. Data that are significantly higher or lower than that of nearby stations to show slight solar cooling over the gap. Around 2020 slight cooling trend since 1978 volcanoes have to do with climate:! Images were captured by NASAs solar Dynamics Observatory between April 15 and 23, 2014near the peak of Industrial! Could a future Grand solar minimum could reduce but not eliminate this warming ( right ) not eliminate warming! Modulation cause small changes in the Suns total brightness at solar minimum could but... Market | a movable trigger: Fossil fuel CO2 sun is getting hotter, satellite data indicate the onset of the 11-year solar variation. Observe the trends over time or transportation reversal of the Suns magnetic poles SSH 1-15.... Number of independent measurements that can affect life on Earth Act to Push Unrelated Financial Regulations by the increase greenhouse! With AFT: the Modern sunspot Record tells us about solar activity then in! And is about 0.1 percent higher than it is at solar maximum is about half the amplitude of chapter... 2014Near the peak of the Industrial Revolution in the mid-1700s coincided with a Gleissberg maximum averages over several months be. //Doi.Org/10.1175/Jcli-D-19-0059.1, Solanki, S. K. ( 2002 ) as the Sun and! And analyse the TSI results from themagnetogram model over the next 100 years Lean was the solar.

Why Did Russell Kill Cable's Family, Articles S