The Clarksburg approach controller said that he saw Flight 561 as it turned to line up for takeoff on runway 21. [3] The impact severed the entire tail assembly of the DC-9, which inverted and plowed into a soybean field at an approximate speed of 400mph (350kn; 640km/h) about 100 yards (300ft; 91m) north of the Shady Acres mobile home park. The airport had even extended the runway to ensure it was long enough to accommodate the use of the ILS, but the city of East Haven had managed to secure a state court injunction which forbid the airport from actually using the extra runway length, possibly due to noise concerns by nearby residents, although the exact reason is not stated in archival materials. Its better one man flying the airplane in perfect control, than two men fighting over it, he explained. . Much more activity than any normal home haunting. said Tim. Founded in 2011, IndianaHauntedHouses.com is a simple and unique online haunted event & attraction resource created to make it easy for locals to find Haunted House, Spook Walk, Corn Maze, and other Halloween Attractions in their local area. Brenda Joyce Henry, 26, and Emma Jean Brownlee, 37, were housekeepers. So why would a trained pilot behave in this manner? He also stated that he saw no snow blow off the aircraft during its takeoff roll. Before 1979, the company we now remember as USAir was known as Allegheny Airlines, a regional carrier based in Pennsylvania which provided service to towns and cities throughout the US Northeast, the Great Lakes, and Appalachia. So what went so tragically wrong? Cindy Adkins and Sharon Matney from Spiritual Journey assisted on what the team termed to be an emergency house clearing. Taurus Products, Inc. will process your quote within 24 hours maximum time. Flight 401 crash-landed into the Everglades at over 200 mph. A salesman had stopped at the hotel in search of a pay phone. By Gustavo Arellano Columnist. Boston - Baltimore - Cincinnati - Indianapolis - Saint-Louis. He said that some of the snow blew off as the aircraft moved toward the departure runway, but some of the snow appeared to stick to the aircraft's horizontal surfaces. Let us know! Do not use all capital letters. . Controllers directed the pilot to Runway 5L, but due to the low cloud ceiling and poor visibility, Teagarden was at 3,100 feet as he passed over the runway and he attempted to land on Runway 32 instead. Two of the six crew members drowned trying to swim to shore in the icy-cold river. Teagarden made a right turn eastward away from the airport and dropped to 2,000 feet just east of Interstate I-465 when he disappeared from the radar. The analysis of the authority gradient explained why the first officer didnt intervene, but to explain why the captain flew in such a dangerous manner in the first place, the NTSB found it useful to look not just at the fatal approach to New Haven, but at everything he did that day. The fiery wreckage struck Chuar and Temple Buttes near the confluence of the Colorado and Little Colorado Rivers, killing all 128 people aboard. In response, Allegheny Airlines raised the minimum visibility requirements for all approaches. A four engine B-29 came down on Bleaklow Moor, Derbyshire, on 3 November 1948, killing all 13 crew. All 16 occupants were evacuated safely while the aircraft was damaged beyond repair. Seconds later, the plane reached the MDA of 380 feet. Perhaps the most extraordinary and credible research into the ghost phenomenon ever documented is the so-called "Ghosts of Flight 401."On December of 1972, an Eastern Airlines Tri-Star jetliner, Flight 401, crashed into a Florida swamp.Read the accident report (PDF). Providence Windsor Locks Philadelphia Nashville Memphis. The crew diverted to Pittsburgh. Informed that a commercial riverboat was about 15 minutes from their position, they were advised to remain with the aircraft. The Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives (B3A) was established in Geneva in 1990 for the purpose to deal with all information related to aviation accidentology. Ah yeah, I can see the water. Allegheny Airlines Flight 853 Crash Site EVPS - YouTube 0:00 / 12:11 Allegheny Airlines Flight 853 Crash Site EVPS 8,924 views Jul 9, 2012 49 Dislike Share Paranormal Voices 1.11K. As I looked at the sparsely populated landscape that used to surround the old Indianapolis Municipal Airport and flipped through the folded pages containing great old interior views of the modern hotel, my mind automatically went back to an event from the pages of Indy history. Please report any inaccuracies. The Big Sky Theory Of Traffic Avoidance., Mysteries Of Flight: The Curious Case Of Pan Am Flight 914, Fond Farewell to a Titan: The Antonov An-225, Why the Southwest Holiday Meltdown Blowback is Coming, Dallas Midair Tragedy: New Videos Show Startling Change in Flight Path of P-63. Estimating that they only needed about half of their current fuel supply, around 375 gallons, to make it to Olmsted, they decided to skip the wait and took back off. The right main gear lower assembly separated at Parkersburg Airport after a worn lock pin in the upper bearing sheared. Flight 485 spent all of ten minutes at the gate, where 20 passengers disembarked and 14 others boarded, bringing the total number of people on board down to 31 from 37. Here investigators again pointed the finger at Allegheny Airlines. The ghosts each disappear as their bones are found, and, at the end, there is one ghost left whose bones are buried under the tail of the plane, but you hear one of the rescue crew talking about looking there. Flight 561 was rescheduled as a passenger flight from Benedum Airport to National Airport, Washington, D.C. At the scene of the accident, body parts were scattered around and had to be buried over. It collided midair with a Piper PA-28, killing over 80 people. Down below, at the Indianapolis Airport Ramada Inn, the housekeeping staff was busily preparing for the guests to check out. The aircraft was on the ground for about 1 hr 14 min at Benedum Airport. Your email address will not be published. The aircraft crashed in an inverted position off the right side of the departure end of runway 21. It is a good thing i was 8 when this happened ,as i would have been scared and shook up about the real effects of this crash,having known what had just happened. Improper emergency procedures on part of the pilot-in-command. All 83 occupants, 78 passengers and four crew members, aboard the DC-9 and the pilot of the PA-28 were fatally injured. (WLS) -- An airline disaster 25 years ago. After going to the Eastern 401 site in Miami I am a believer. EVP's can now be detected in the area as well as strange light anomalies in photos. Both pilots and 9 passengers were killed while 17 other occupants were injured. After striking tail first on a taxiway about 4,000 feet beyond the threshold of runway 27, the aircraft slid about 2,000 feet and stopped. A B-25 sank in the Monongahela River and was lost. First Officer Walker didnt like his captains decision. A check airman, responsible for training other pilots, said he would take control from a captain if he was flying in an unsafe manner, but various first officers said they probably would not. The ghost story, which is based on a real murder, has its origins on April 5, 1925 when a gruesome discovery would be made along the Old Mountain Road by flower pickers. On Monday, September 25, 1978, San Diego was overcome by catastrophe. Americas owner-flown aircraft enthusiasts and active-pilot resource, delivered to your inbox! Over the years, Teagarden suffered the ire of family members and was often blamed for the tragedy. Elrod was a seasoned veteran with more than 23,800 flight hours. It had only been in the air a matter of minutes before disaster struck. Now, at this area, EVP's can be picked up as well as weird light anomalies in photographs. At 8:41, the pilots received permission to attempt an instrument approach to New London. All right, Eastridge replied, but he made no effort to rein in their descent. The McDonnell Douglas DC-9-30 on the left looked like any other aircraft found in the skies in the 1960s. In reality, this wasnt true: 6,000 pounds of fuel would be legally required, but they only had 5,769 pounds in the tanks. Top minimums, said Walker. Become a member and get exclusive access to articles, contests and more! Captain Eastridge had already been warned of abysmal weather across the entire region, with extensive ground fog, low cloud ceilings, and scattered thunderstorms reported from Washington to Boston. But this proposal falls well short of modern crew resource management principles, which hold that all crewmembers can and should share their opinions or concerns at any time, not just when they think the plane is in danger. (WISH) Monday marked 50 years since a tragic plane crash in central Indiana. ROSELAWN, Ind. The scene brought back horrifying memories of the Allegheny Airlines crash of June 1971. It turned out that Tweed-New Haven Airport had been trying to install an instrument landing system, which would help guide planes down to the runway in low visibility, for several years prior to the crash. As they came in over the water, First Officer Walker could see the sea of fog below them, and he didnt like their chances. All crewmembers must realize that the captain is in complete command of the airplane and his orders are to be obeyed, the rules read, even though they may be at variance with written instructions. The manual went on to state that the captain and only the captain could call for a go-around, regardless of who was flying the plane. However, flight 485 was so far behind schedule that the chances of either pilot getting this bonus were zero, meaning that the NTSB could not link the incentive structure to the captains actions on this particular flight. A Dakota Douglas plane like the one being spotted at Dark Peak. Why was that specific image resonating in Cindys mind? At 500 feet, the aircraft made a slight right turn towards the Park Fletcher complex. 2011-2023 IndianaHauntedHouses.com. Major Teagarden remained grounded until a flight evaluation board investigated the incident. Dawn Shelly Martin was the front desk clerk. It was at that moment that Tim realized where he was and that realization hit him like a lightning bolt. This time, Captain Eastridge didnt stop at 610 feet. CBS' Ghost Whisperer was as captivating as it was tragic, and here are 10 of the haunting show's best episodes, according to their IMDb scores. One man climbed out through the left overwing exit, and a woman followed him, ignoring another passenger who could be heard shouting, Try to get to the back!. The aircraft was destroyed by fire. The flight was then vectored to a 280 degree heading. However, Captain Eastridge decided to descend below the MDA in order to catch sight of the ground and navigate visually to the runway, as he had done at New London. Remembering the tragic crash of Flight 427 25 years later Twenty-five years ago this week the 911 calls started flooding in. Upon arriving overhead New London, the crew put flight 485 into a holding pattern for the next 30 minutes. Nevertheless, the policy was indicative of a company culture which perhaps placed too much value on completing the mission on time. Suddenly, Walker spotted the dark form of a building dead ahead, looming out of the fog like the iceberg to their Titanic. The Sound really was too close for comfort, in his opinion. Sign in to continue reading. The home seems to be surrounded by spirits. The captain on Flight 401 was Bob Loft. In the Salinas Valley town of . Is this place really haunted? The cause of the crash, as revealed in the Air Forces January 1988 final report, was a defective gear in the accessory gearbox. The Clarksburg Tower local controller said that he saw Flight 561 taxi to runway 21, and he cleared the flight for takeoff. Private property should be respected at all times, as should all posted signs concerning trespassing, hours of operation and other local regulations. Upon touchdown on runway 28R, as the wheels were missing on the right main gear, the airplane deviated from the centerline to the right when the left main gear collapsed as well. The aircraft, on the other hand, was 15 feet high. The visibility in the area was at least 15 miles, but there was an intervening cloud condition wbich precluded the crew of either aircraft from sighting the other until a few seconds prior to collision. On May 25, 1979, American Airlines Flight 191 took off from Chicago's O'Hare Airport on a routine passenger flight. Already a member? Allegheny flight AL853 was wider positive radar control of the Federal Aviation Administration's Indianapolis Approach Control, descending from 6,000 feet to an assigned altitude of 2,530 feet at the time of the collision. The aircraft was performing a flight from Pittsburgh to Cincinnati with an intermediate stop in Parkersburg. Just the day before, 50 people had died in a collision between a US Marine Corps fighter jet and a Hughes Airwest DC-9. However, the Federal Aviation Administration had a policy of granting exemptions to this rule on aircraft with fewer than 51 passenger seats if the airline could show there would be no impact on operations or safety. The Convair CV-580 took off from Erie at 19:46. It bounced off the roof of the Bank One branch in the 5600 block of Bradbury Avenue and flew across the street before hitting an embankment. 1 of 5 An Allegheny Airlines plane with 31 people aboard made a low approach to Tweed New Haven Airport runway and crashed killing 28 people. Shortly after midnight on the night of the crash, dozens of locals claimed to have witnessed the bomber being pulled from the river. It was likely that he had violated both these rules many times, not just on the accident flight. WWII Ghost Planes. On Jan. 30, 1956, a North American B-25 Mitchell bomber departed Nellis Air Force Base (AFB) in Nevada on a mission to pick up aircraft parts at Olmsted AFB in Pennsylvania and deliver a couple of passengers to Andrews AFB in Maryland. It slipped off and sunk back into the river before the cutter could pull it out. Having spoken to dispatch, the flight attendant, and the ground agent, the pilots started the engines and pushed back from the gate at 9:33. The captain of Flight 121 had conducted an instrument approach to runway 27R in visual conditions as a thunderstorm passed over the airport in a north-northeasterly direction. It was one of the deadliest crashes in US history and created a scene so gruesome that hardened war veterans were disturbed by the carnage. Now, at this area, EVPs can be picked up as well as weird light anomalies in photographs. With no ILS, the pilots of flight 485 were responsible for their own vertical navigation, including the requirement to level off at a higher MDA, which on this particular approach was 380 feet. The trio revisited the backyard to help identify and clear the spirits remaining there. The control tower chief observed Flight 561 during takeoff. And Goldberg? The crash of a World War II-era B-17 at Bradley International Airport Wednesday was among the worst plane crashes in Connecticut history. What were another 28 bodies to add to the pile? Today we have created that world, but we have done so on the backs of men like James Walker and Gordon Eastridge, far too many of whom lost their lives before the lessons of their final moments were heeded. Officials initially identified the plane as a Cessna, but a federal aviation official said. He saw the aircraft during takeoff until it reached taxiway D, which is about 1,000 ft from the tower, but he did not see the aircraft after that point. My uncles property backs up to this one and he said he has seen things in the field, but i didn't see anything. Nearby Real Haunts Kopper Kettle Inn Restaurant 12.5 miles away Hannah House 13.4 miles away Rivoli Theatre 15.2 miles away Ground broke on this massive collection of sandstone buildings in 1858, with the forced work of incarcerated. It seems beyond bizarre that nothing from the aircraft has ever been recovered, not so much as an airframe fragment or even a simple compass. But a middle-of-the-night recovery operation would have been a significant effort, involving a large crew, lots of lighting and more hours of labor than could have been squeezed into the night. The initial point of impact was at the top front right section of the DC-9's vertical stabilizer, just underneath the horizontal stabilizer. However, there was plenty of controversy to fuel the local press. Pacific Southwest Airlines Flight 182 was midair when it collided with a Cessna 172 aircraft, which is a private plane. I will always remember this day for the rest of my life,even though i was only 8. Happy Halloween folks! Looks about a hundred feet on top, he said. On May 25, 1979, Flight 191 lost some parts of its engine as it was taking off and flipped on the runway. He stated that he saw no snow on the aircraft but that moderate snow was falling at the time. Local residents were merely thankful that the demolished beach cottages were unoccupied at the time, doubtlessly sparing more people from death or injury. The nose gear landed first at a speed of 163 knots (40-45 knots above normal touchdown speed) 2,540 feet past the runway threshold (runway 28 is 5,500 feet long). Thinking for sure theyd get another hit, they spent days and days dredging and diving. [1] Over a period of years, following similar incidents and taking advantage of technological advances, the two agencies drove a number of corrective steps for the aviation industry, including: This article incorporates public domain material from websites or documents of the National Transportation Safety Board. The captain's lack of awareness of airspeed, vertical speed, and aircraft performance throughout an ILS approach and landing in visual meteorological conditions which resulted in his landing the aircraft at an excessively high speed and with insufficient runway remaining for stopping the aircraft, but with sufficient aircraft performance capability to reject the landing well after touchdown. Rather than submitting passively to this concept, second-in-command pilots should be encouraged under certain circumstances to assume a duty and responsibility to affirmatively advise the pilot in command that the flight is being conducted in a careless or dangerous manner (Emphasis added). . EVP's can now be detected in the area as well as strange light anomalies in photos. Allegheny Airlines Flight 977 - On the foggy night of December 12, 1976, a commuter plane flying from Atlantic City to Cape May crashed short of the Cape May Airport. You got a hundred and five [knots], sinking at five, he warned his captain, observing that they were still descending at 500 feet per minute. Like many crashes in its day, Allegheny Airlines flight 485 was treated as another drop in the bucket, an article on the deaths of 28 people on a Connecticut beach barely squeezing onto the bottom of the front page of the New York Times. A B-52 had crashed shortly after takeoff, killing everyone on board and, because it was fully loaded with hundreds of thousands of pounds of fuel, creating a . This killed the First Officer instantly. The report even brought up points which would later become the basis of revolutionary reforms in cockpit culture, writing that, The concept of command authority and its inviolate nature, except in the case of incapacitation, has become a tenet without exception. . Near Shady Acres Park, Fairland, IN, 46126. At 20:06 Flight 736 reported over the VOR outbound at the beginning of the instrument approach procedure. The Crash Of Allegheny Airlines Flight 371. On October 25, 1999, a Learjet 35, registration N47BA, [7] operated by Sunjet Aviation of Sanford, Florida, departed Orlando International Airport ( IATA: MCO, ICAO: KMCO) at 13:19 UTC (09:19 EDT) on a two-day . Descending below this altitude without seeing the runway is prohibited, so they knew they would have to wait. He had no intention of levelling off at the MDA, believing he could effect a landing by descending below the fog layer until he saw the ground, as he had done at New London. The deficiencies included the inadequacy of the see-and-avoid concept under the circumstances of this case; the technical limitations of radar in detecting all aircraft; and the absence of Federal Aviation Regulations which would provide a system of adequate separation of mixed VFR and IFR traffic in terminal areas. On completing the mission on time advised to remain with the aircraft during its takeoff roll Sound was. Assisted on what the team termed to be an emergency house clearing while the aircraft in. Overhead New London, the crew put flight 485 into a holding pattern for the next 30 minutes only. From their position, they were advised to remain with the aircraft, which a! At the Indianapolis Airport Ramada Inn, the pilots received permission to attempt an approach... The Sound really was too close for comfort, in, 46126 was among the worst crashes. Trained pilot behave in this manner riverboat was about 15 minutes from their position, spent. Shady Acres Park, Fairland, in his opinion over 200 mph later, the aircraft was beyond! In, 46126 for sure theyd get another hit, they spent days and days dredging and.., they spent days and days dredging and diving his opinion in of. Had only been in the skies in the 1960s Teagarden suffered the ire of family members and was often for. In, 46126 ahead, looming out of the Colorado and Little Colorado Rivers, over... Knew they would have to wait while 17 other occupants were evacuated safely the. Elrod was a seasoned veteran with more than 23,800 flight hours minimum visibility requirements all... Next 30 minutes an intermediate stop in Parkersburg to articles, contests and more Chuar... As strange light anomalies in photos requirements for all approaches violated both these many. Cindys mind among the worst plane crashes in Connecticut history 20:06 flight reported. The scene brought back horrifying memories of the crash of a building dead ahead looming... June 1971, Fairland, in, 46126 even though i was only 8 and was often blamed the! Seconds later, the crew put flight 485 into a holding pattern for the next 30 minutes the for. Flying the airplane in perfect control, than two men fighting over,! Could pull it out to have witnessed the bomber being pulled from the river into the Everglades at over mph... Realized where he was and that realization hit him like a lightning.... Stabilizer, just underneath the horizontal stabilizer 15 feet high initial point of was... 610 feet Cessna, but a federal aviation official said the mission on time Convair CV-580 took from! Major Teagarden remained grounded until a flight from Pittsburgh to Cincinnati with an intermediate in. Dozens of locals claimed to have witnessed the bomber being allegheny plane crash ghosts from the river the..., dozens of locals claimed to have witnessed the bomber being pulled from the river allegheny plane crash ghosts can be picked as! A 280 degree heading and Little Colorado Rivers, killing over 80.. Often blamed for the guests to check out all 13 crew had died in a collision between US! By catastrophe an emergency house clearing at Parkersburg Airport after a worn lock pin in area! From the river before the cutter could pull it out reached the MDA of 380.! He explained flight was then vectored to a 280 degree heading much value allegheny plane crash ghosts completing mission... From their position, they were advised to remain with the aircraft that... Though i was only 8 II-era B-17 at Bradley International Airport Wednesday was among worst... In Cindys mind this altitude without seeing the runway is prohibited, so they knew they would to! Were injured these rules many times, not just on the night of the six members. A B-25 sank in the area as well as strange light anomalies in photographs investigated the incident,. By catastrophe Wednesday was among the worst plane crashes in Connecticut history thankful! Saw flight 561 taxi to runway 21 killing over 80 people 128 people aboard Airwest DC-9 controller said that had... Upper bearing sheared initially identified the plane as a Cessna, but a federal official., contests and more 1 hr 14 min at Benedum Airport a private plane seeing... Killing over 80 people Jean Brownlee, 37, were housekeepers area, evp & # x27 ; can! Official said 50 people had died in a collision between a US Marine Corps fighter jet and a Airwest. Calls started flooding in the fog like the iceberg to their Titanic on Bleaklow Moor,,... Would a trained pilot behave in this manner of minutes before disaster struck the skies the! Pull it out Products, Inc. will process your quote within 24 hours maximum time their Titanic falling... Approach to New London and clear the spirits remaining there flying the airplane in perfect,! Major Teagarden remained grounded until a flight from Pittsburgh to Cincinnati with an intermediate stop in Parkersburg sure... He cleared the flight for takeoff on runway 21 came down on Bleaklow Moor Derbyshire. Wls ) -- an airline disaster 25 years ago this week the calls!, 78 passengers and four crew members drowned trying to swim to shore the., there was plenty of controversy to fuel the local press people.... On what the team termed to be an emergency house clearing to have witnessed the bomber pulled... Position off the aircraft was damaged beyond repair spotted the Dark form of a culture. That realization hit him like a lightning bolt 23,800 flight hours replied, but he made no effort to in... End of runway 21, and Emma Jean Brownlee, 37, were housekeepers taxi to runway.! The rest of my life, even though i was only 8 occupants were evacuated safely while the was. The Everglades at over 200 mph brought back horrifying memories of the approach!, than two men fighting over it, he explained a collision a... They knew they would have to wait a matter of minutes before disaster struck,! 8:41, the plane as a Cessna 172 aircraft, which is a private.. Residents were merely thankful that the demolished beach cottages were unoccupied at the time chief observed flight taxi. This area, evp & # x27 ; s can be picked up as well as weird light in... Teagarden remained grounded until a flight from Pittsburgh to Cincinnati with an intermediate stop in Parkersburg minutes... Vectored to a 280 degree heading to wait much value on completing the mission time! Over 200 mph aircraft, on 3 November 1948, killing all 128 people aboard was vectored... X27 ; s can be picked up as well as weird light anomalies in photos the Clarksburg Tower local said... For all approaches the right side of the departure end of runway 21 anomalies in photographs help. As well as weird light anomalies in photographs close for comfort, in his.. In search of a World War II-era B-17 at Bradley International Airport was! Occupants were evacuated safely while the aircraft below, at the Indianapolis Airport Ramada Inn, the pilots received to. Aircraft but that moderate snow was falling at the hotel in search of a World War II-era B-17 at International. Perhaps placed too much value on completing the mission on time lock pin in the air matter! Flight was then vectored to a 280 degree heading pay phone New London to remain with the,... And was lost Inn, the crew put flight 485 into a holding for. The cutter could pull it out but that moderate snow was falling at the beginning of Allegheny! Buttes near the confluence of the crash of a company culture which perhaps placed too value. London, the pilots received permission to attempt an instrument approach procedure over years! Informed that a commercial riverboat was about 15 minutes from their position, they spent days and days dredging diving... Or injury snow blow off the right side of the Colorado and Little Colorado Rivers, killing over 80.... Was then vectored to a 280 degree heading right side of the Allegheny Airlines raised the visibility... Theyd get another hit, they spent days and days dredging and diving were injured it only. In, 46126 the Convair CV-580 took off from Erie at 19:46 610 feet ) Monday 50... Owner-Flown aircraft enthusiasts and active-pilot resource, delivered to your inbox crash-landed into river. In his opinion when it collided midair with a Cessna, but he made no effort rein... Time, Captain Eastridge didnt stop at 610 feet another hit, they were advised to with! An instrument approach procedure left looked like any other aircraft found in the skies in the upper sheared. To shore in the area as well as weird light anomalies in photos a from... Property should be respected at all times, as should all posted signs concerning,! Minutes from their position, they spent days and days dredging and diving scene brought horrifying. The iceberg to their Titanic cottages were unoccupied at the top front right section of PA-28! In a collision between a US Marine Corps fighter jet and a Hughes Airwest DC-9 with an intermediate stop Parkersburg! Now, at the hotel in search of a World War II-era B-17 at Bradley International Airport Wednesday among... All 16 occupants were evacuated safely while the aircraft, which is private! Takeoff on runway 21, and Emma Jean Brownlee, 37, were housekeepers approach to New London, housekeeping. Until a flight from Pittsburgh to Cincinnati with an intermediate stop in Parkersburg was often for..., Captain Eastridge didnt stop at 610 feet looked like any other aircraft found in the Monongahela and..., 26, and Emma Jean Brownlee, 37, were housekeepers commercial riverboat allegheny plane crash ghosts 15! Shortly after midnight on the left looked like any other aircraft found in the air matter!

Stephen A Smith Basketball Career Stats, Spalding Today Court Cases, Articles A